counterfactual fairness
What It Means
Counterfactual fairness tests whether an AI system would make the same decision about a person if their protected characteristics (like race or gender) were different, but everything else about them stayed the same. It's essentially asking 'would this loan approval, hiring decision, or medical recommendation be identical if this person were a different race or gender but had the exact same qualifications and circumstances?' This requires understanding the causal relationships between different factors that influence outcomes.
Why Chief AI Officers Care
This is one of the most rigorous fairness standards but also one of the hardest to implement, requiring detailed causal models that most organizations don't have. It's becoming increasingly relevant for regulatory compliance as lawmakers push for 'but-for' causation tests in discrimination cases. The technical complexity and data requirements make this expensive to implement, but it provides the strongest legal defense against bias claims.
Real-World Example
A bank's mortgage approval system would be counterfactually fair if it would approve the same loan for both a Black applicant and white applicant who have identical income, credit scores, employment history, and debt levels. The system fails this test if it's influenced by factors like neighborhood demographics that correlate with race, even if race isn't directly used as an input variable.
Common Confusion
People often confuse this with simpler fairness metrics that just compare approval rates across groups. Counterfactual fairness is much more demanding because it requires proving the decision would be identical for the same individual with different protected attributes, not just that groups are treated similarly on average.
Industry-Specific Applications
See how this term applies to healthcare, finance, manufacturing, government, tech, and insurance.
Healthcare: In healthcare AI, counterfactual fairness ensures that diagnostic recommendations, treatment plans, or risk assessments ...
Finance: In finance, counterfactual fairness ensures lending, insurance, and investment decisions remain consistent regardless of...
Premium content locked
Includes:
- 6 industry-specific applications
- Relevant regulations by sector
- Real compliance scenarios
- Implementation guidance
Technical Definitions
NISTNational Institute of Standards and Technology
"A fairness metric that checks whether a classifier produces the same result for one individual as it does for another individual who is identical to the first, except with respect to one or more sensitive attributes. Evaluating a classifier for counterfactual fairness is one method for surfacing potential sources of bias in a model"Source: aime_measurement_2022, citing Machine Learning Glossary by Google
"Given a predictive problem with fairness considerations, where A, X and Y represent the protected attributes, remaining attributes, and output of interest respectively, let us assume that we are given a causal model (U; V; F), where V = A \cup X. We postulate the following criterion for predictors of Y . Definition 5 (Counterfactual fairness). Predictor ^Y is counterfactually fair if under any context X = x and A = a, P( ^Y_{A <- a} (U) = y | X = x; A = a) = P( ^Y_{A <- a')(U) = y | X = x;A = a); (1) for all y and for any value a' attainable by A."Source: kusner_counterfactual_2017
Discuss This Term with Your AI Assistant
Ask how "counterfactual fairness" applies to your specific use case and regulatory context.
Start Free Trial